AAArticle template

This article may not be reproduced in any form, print or digital, without express written permission from the author, Deborah Allnutt. Copyright 2026.

by Deborah Allnutt 2026


This article may not be reproduced in any form, print or digital, without express written permission from the author, Deborah Allnutt. Copyright 202
6




AN AFTER SHOW AH-HA MOMENT

Taking Another Look at my Buttons

Sometime a few years back, I stopped competing in any competitions. No particular reason why, just stopped. I had my share of blue, red, and green ribbons, but they weren’t incentive even when I competed and suddenly, they seemed much less so. Then just as suddenly, it seemed time to start competing again. My state’s spring show what on the horizon and I had written and submitted two awards. The first was an award for moonglows. The second was shapes, specialized to anything but round, i.e., hearts, spindles, rectangles, squares, etc. It was after this competition that I began to look at my buttons differently.

During this competition hiatus I still purchased buttons. Buttons bring me joy and there’s never been one purchased just because it fits some criteria to complete a tray. My focus was on purchasing as many materials as possible for a subject and anything that came along with it was just a happy bonus. Over the years I thought if competition were to happen again, having a variety of materials would be halfway to a completed tray. That idea was way off base.

The first award I entered, moonglows, was straightforward and came together with little effort. The second award, shapes, anything but round, was fun to put together, but I knew going in it wasn’t a winner but couldn’t put my finger on why. When I saw the first and second place trays, all became clear, and the judges even wrote in on the tray slip and confirmed it; their buttons had more techniques. We all had 25 different materials, but theirs were just better. Their trays included pipestone, leather, shell, and casein, materials I rarely consider. Their trays were vibrant, showcasing pastes, cut steels, and more. Mine was flat and basic. The first lesson I learned from this competition was to get out of my comfort zone, to look beyond the obvious, and explore and learn about more materials.

Gay 90’s are a favorite of mine. Over the years as I’ve collected one here and there, I have paid attention to things like the shape and color of the stones, the settings, and giving a cursory thought to embellishments. It wasn’t until after this show and the judge’s comment on my third place tray that I really too a hard look at what I had. Then I not only saw a beautiful button in front of me, but one that had several things going for it. First, it’s an oval shape. Second, it’s set in copper. Third, it has tow tear shaped amethyst stones divided by five clear pastes set on an angle. Look at that beautiful leaf border.

I took this approach to some of my other buttons and was really surprised at what I had, what I had missed. The nuances and beauty of these buttons opened up. For example, this large celluloid has an imitation tortoise shell background, an all over (diaper) pattern, and a horn center. Lovely. This small design under glass spider has three materials, brass and leather sitting atop either horn or composition.

But this article isn’t really about competition. It’s an encouragement to all of us to learn about what we have. It’s about stretching ourselves to discover and study a variety of materials, a button’s origins, its construction. It’s about learning the difference between Bakelite and casein. It’s about knowing whether something been inlaid or inset. WBA does not hold competitions nor does it advise on trays. What WBA does do is try to help you understand what you hold in your hand. We study materials, techniques, button artists, a button’s age, back marks, and anything else to help us understand our tiny treasures. Worksheets can be found on our website that will guide you and help you learn about a variety of materials and subjects.

The wonderful thing about button collecting is that there is always something new to discover. Recently WBA hosted a program by Alan Hepburn on West’s Patent Solitaires. After nearly 30 years of button collecting these remained unknown to me until now. Perhaps it will be the beginning of a new hunt for me and maybe some other collectors who were previously unaware of these buttons, but totally mesmerized by them.

You don’t have to have competition ready trays on your walls. You just need to love what you have. You need to know what you have. Learning about your buttons and sharing that information with your club and others is an important part of collecting, something we strive for here at WBA. We become a much smarter and stronger when we are all involved in our education.

*Alan Hepburn has written four articles about West’s Patent Solitaires and which can be found on the website. The video taped program will be available for viewing at a later date.